Kris Jenner, 63, took to Instagram to share what she believed were some adorable black and white photos of her family in honour of her mother Mary Jo (MJ) Campbell’s 85th birthday, but the reaction she received about one in particular was not quite what she expected. In the headline-making photo, Kris’ daughters, Kourtney Kardashian, 40, and Khloe Kardashian, 35, can be seen posing with Kim Kardashian’s daughter North West, 6, who stood out for wearing what looked like a nose ring on her nose.

Once Kris posted the celebratory pics, it didn’t take long for followers to point out their opinions about North’s nose ring and they geared their frustration at Kim for allowing her young daughter wear the piece of jewelry.

Although Kim didn’t respond to comments directly, she made sure to take to her Instagram story to clear up the assumptions that North’s nose ring was real. “Fake nose ring alert!!!” she captioned the same photo to her story.